Choose an Instagram agency on four things: who leads your account, whether their taste fits your brand, how approvals work, and what’s in the written scope. Ask the 12 questions below on your first call, get the answers in writing, and walk away from anyone who guarantees followers or won’t put the scope on paper.
Most top results are written for performance marketers: ad accounts, pixels, conversion tests. They rarely ask about taste, or how to tell an agency’s own channel from client results. Few warn you to check that “case studies” are real client work shown with permission. For a brand, founder or artist, those questions matter most.
Before you start: know what you’re hiring for
Write three lines before any call:
- What should change? (e.g. “Our account looks generic,” “I need to post consistently,” “We’re relaunching.”)
- What’s in scope? Strategy, creative direction, content, publishing, community, promotion.
- Who approves? You, a partner, a team.
This turns sales calls into comparisons.
The 12 questions
About people
1. Who will lead my account day to day? The person on the pitch call is not always the person doing the work. Ask for a name. At Grownup Systems, our team delivers the work, and Watts's creative perspective shapes it.
2. What have you built on a channel you control? An agency’s own channel shows its taste with no client in the way. Ask them to label it as owned work rather than a client result.
3. Can I see client work, and do you have permission to show it? Good agencies publish client work only with permission and evidence. Be wary of logos with no story behind them. (Grownup Systems publishes no client work yet and says so on its Work page.)
About the work
4. How will you define the direction of my account? Look for a process: point of view, visual direction, voice. If the answer is “we’ll post trending Reels,” you are hearing a volume plan with no direction behind it. For what the role covers, see what an Instagram creative director does.
5. Who makes the content, and how? In-house, freelancers, stock, or your own photos. All can work. Know which one you’re buying.
6. How many posts, in which formats, per month? Get a number. “Consistent posting” is not a deliverable.
About control
7. What’s the approval process? Nothing should go live without your sign-off. Ask how drafts reach you, how many revision rounds are included, and what happens if you change a post after approval.
8. How will you access my account? Proper access, not your password. You stay the owner of the account and the content.
9. If you use AI tools, where do humans stay in control? A fair question in 2026. Ask whether any system can publish, message or commit on its own. At Grownup Systems, approval is recorded for an exact content version, and an edit needs a new approval.
About money and terms
10. What’s included in the fee, and what’s priced separately? Ask specifically about promotion, paid placements and community management. (See how much Instagram management costs.)
11. Will I get the scope, schedule and fee in writing before I pay? This should be a yes. Anything else is a risk.
12. How do we review what’s working, and how do we end the engagement? Ask how often you’ll review results, which measures matter for your goal, and the notice and handoff terms.
Agency scorecard
Score each agency 0–2 per row after the call.
| What to check | Good answer | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Who leads | A named senior person | “The team” |
| Taste | Owned channel you admire | No work of their own |
| Client proof | Permissioned, explained | Logos with no context |
| Direction | Clear process | “We follow trends” |
| Deliverables | Numbers and formats | “Consistent posting” |
| Approvals | You sign off every post | They post freely |
| Access | Proper access, you own it | Asks for your password |
| Pricing | Scope, extras priced apart | One unexplained total |
| Terms | Written before payment | Verbal promises |
| Growth claims | Honest about what’s in their control | Guaranteed followers |
Red flags
- Guaranteed follower counts or “viral” promises
- Pressure to sign before a written scope
- Requests for your password
- Client logos they can’t explain
- Promotion bundled in with no separate fee
Hiring checklist
- I wrote down what should change, what’s in scope, and who approves
- I asked all 12 questions and got written answers
- I know the name of the person leading my account
- I’ve reviewed their own channel and any permissioned client work
- Deliverables and formats are numbers, not adjectives
- I approve every post before it’s published
- Access doesn’t require sharing my password
- Promotion and extras are priced separately
- Scope, schedule and fee are in writing before I pay
- I know how to review results and how to end the engagement
How Grownup Systems answers these
- Who leads: Watts, founder, behind @love.watts. Meet Watts.
- Scope: strategy, creative direction, content and account management, from direction to publishing. See Instagram management.
- Approvals: posts are made with your approval before publishing.
- Fee: estimate on request; deliverables, schedule, approvals and fee agreed in writing before work starts.
- Promotion: through Love Watts or another channel, scoped and priced separately.
Request a demo and bring these 12 questions.